dark matter essay
(C) 2013
  • about
    • values
    • competences >
      • china
      • intellectual property >
        • What is original?
        • talks & lectures
      • work & vocation
      • personal and organizational development >
        • definitions and techniques
        • syst lexicon
        • projection #1
        • projection #2
        • projection #3
  • blog
  • STP journal
  • book reviews
    • Boy by Roald Dahl
    • Digital Dementia by Manfred Spitzer
    • Evolution's Meaning and Objective by Pierre Teilhard de Chardin
    • Focus - The Hidden Driver of Excellence by Daniel Goleman
    • Going Solo by Roald Dahl
    • Homo Deus by Yuval N. Harari
    • Iron John by Robert Bly
    • Irresistible by Adam Alter
    • Reinventing Organizations by Frederic Laloux
    • Steve Jobs by Walter Isaakson
    • The Idle Parent by Tom Hodgkinson
    • The Great Disruption by Francis Fukuyama
    • The Monk Who Sold His Ferarri by Robin Sharma
    • The Organized Mind by Daniel Levitin
    • The Practice of the Wild by Gary Snyder
    • Weltentwerfen by Friedrich Boerries
    • World Order by Henry Kissinger
  • film reviews
    • Alphabet (2013)
    • Around the World in 80 Days (1956)
    • Bad Santa (2003)
    • Captain Fantastic (2016)
    • Concussion (2016)
    • Demain | Tomorrow
    • East is East (1999)
    • Her (2013)
    • Kinsey (2004)
    • Laura Croft II - The Cradle of Life
    • Le Planete Sauvage (1973)
    • Pope Francis by Wim Wenders
    • Suzaku (1997)
    • SIlence (2016)
    • The Challenges of Rudolf Steiner (2011)
    • The Program (2015)
    • The Salt of the Earth (2014)
    • The Straight Story (1999)
  • topic essays
    • anthropology >
      • on economics >
        • Do we reward our contributions to society the way we should?
        • International Tax Evasion
        • capitalism
        • on profit, passion & purpose
      • on humor
      • on politics >
        • zur lage der nation: le grand peur II
        • Analyse NR Wahl 2013
        • zur lage der nation
        • Wutbürger - anger citizens
        • World Order - Book Review
      • Identity: Warum mich Trachten entfremden
      • on gender and sexuality
      • on religion
    • art
    • creativity >
      • Transforming the IP System
    • education >
      • Mindful Parenting
      • Alphabet - Documentary Review
      • Henry Kissinger on Education
      • learning environment
      • Musicalized - Rich Music for Poor Times
      • screen education
      • Sting on how he became to be what he is and creativity
      • On Bi- and Multilingual Instruction
      • A Playground of Growth
      • On Procrastination
    • neurology >
      • On Football and Oxytocin
    • on nutrition
    • psychology >
      • algorithm of love
      • art of loving
      • applied virtues
      • emotional intelligence
      • grundformen der angst
      • grit - key to success
      • happiness
      • on love and grief
      • triangular love
      • yale intro to psychology
    • quotes worth quoting
    • sports >
      • kiting
      • yoga
      • squash
    • writing
  • travel essays
    • one step into camino frances
    • journey to the center of the earth
    • Alto Adige - An Example how European Integration can Succeed
    • on the friendship highway
    • en viaje de andalusia
    • sawasdee krub - a quiet holiday in thailand
    • Viking Myths and Hanseatic Harmony
    • How Airbnb Explains Bureaucratic Futilism and Why the Chinese hukou System Could be a Solution to the European Migration Crisis
    • On Slovenia and Integration or Isolation in Post Nationalist Europe
    • who moved my swiss cheese?
    • On Taiwan and its Identity Crisis
    • On Nippon Sakoku
    • Expectations of and Deliveries in Down Under
    • Silence on Kumano Kodo
    • Zwischen der pannonischen und mandschurischen Ebene treibend
    • Thoughts on Freedom and Order While Dozing in Berlin
    • On Interrail and Climate Ticket
    • On Morroco, Islam and Faithfulness
  • contact

Medical Madness: A Product of American Capitalism and Chinese Moral Corruption

9/22/2016

0 Comments

 
Picture
Medical Madness: A Product of American Capitalism and Chinese Moral Corruption
 
About two years ago we noticed that our son’s foreskin didn’t retract properly and sometimes got infected. Nothing serious, but I wanted it to be checked and therefore took him then to United Family Hospital Puxi, where he was also born in 2012. The physician told us, that we should wait for another two years for the foreskin to open up on its own. A few weeks ago I consulted the same physician, Dr. Hatti Wang, again, and she said that a surgery is inevitable.
 
There was no further diagnosis neither an explanation of the surgical procedure, but both a pre-OP check date and a surgery date was arranged. I was then of the opinion that we would receive a complete diagnosis and an explanation of the surgery procedure during the pre-OP check, but realized yesterday during the pre-OP appointment, that a nurse waited for us to get a blood sample only. No physician, no surgeon, nothing of additional information.
 
I explained to the nurse, that I am still missing important information, e.g. a proper diagnosis or which kind of anesthetics will be applied. The nurse understood my concerns and called the head of the surgical department Dr. Zhang Zhuo. It is mainly this consultation which not only disappointed me, but actually confirmed my lost trust in a system of profit driven clinics. You simply can’t run a health institution on a capitalist foundation and employ morally corrupted staff.
 
Dr. Zhang told me that
  1. The medical condition my son suffers from is called phimosis.
  2. The probability, that our son’s foreskin opens up on its own, is at age 4 close to zero.
  3. A surgery is therefore inevitable.
  4. Delaying the surgery will lead to painful infections.
  5. Full anesthesia is mandatory for the safety of the child.
 
We arrived at these conclusions only because I insisted to get a complete consultation and I told Dr. Zhang that a parent does not want to perform surgery on his child if there is no imminent reason to do so. He said that he understood my concerns. But I couldn’t help to observe a sly salesperson’s smile throughout our conversation. And I have to give Dr. Zhang and Dr. Wang their credits: as medical doctors they have way more knowledge than the average patient. But, I told myself, didn’t they swear the Hippocratic Oath, i.e. aren’t they obliged to help their patients and must not do harm.
 
Well, lets not get into an ethical discussion here. Let’s stick to the facts:

  1. Our son does not suffer from acute pain nor were the infections serious or lasting. We therefore do not see an imminent reason to perform surgery.
  2. Wikipedia writes that physiologic phimosis, common in males 10 years of age and younger, is normal, and does not require intervention. Non-retractile foreskin usually becomes retractable during the course of puberty.
  3. A local anesthesia costs only a fraction of a full anesthesia.  
I therefore conclude, that both Dr. Zhang and Dr. Wang intentionally provided false medical information. They acted rather as sales persons than as physicians. No harm done, yet, but the risk of full anesthesia and the risk of performing an unnecessary surgery was accepted in order to generate additional turnover for their employer and surely some bonus for themselves.
 
It is not my intention to blame these individuals, although they, too, have a responsibility to take a step back and inquire into what they do and why. I rather ask here, why we develop such systems of greed and fraud. On several different occasions, and in different industries I have heard people say, that the worst features of humanity are produced when American capitalism merges with Chinese corrupted morals, i.e. when refined greed meets refined fraud.
 
Dr. Zhang told me during our discussion on the necessity of full anesthesia, that he worked in a local Shanghai hospital before joining United Family. There, only a local anesthesia is implemented on children, and he is convinced that from a medical point of view, a full anesthesia is safer. Well, I am not a physician, and there will be pro and con arguments for full anesthesia, but I know that United Family had a long negotiation with our insurance provider to explain the necessity of a 30k CNY surgery; a third of which for anesthesia.
 
This is also the time and place to do some self criticism. We are in the lucky situation that we have an international health insurance, which covers globally pretty everything apart from dental care. That’s luxury, considering that a substantial fraction of humanity must survive without any insurance at all. We have come to cherish this luxury, but we have also been trapped in the system. If high-end medical care is free of charge, one is inclined to stop reflecting about the necessity of services provided. I made that mistake, when I consulted United Family for our son’s condition.
 
We will therefore change this habit; and even though our insurance might cover some services, we will check ourselves if we really need them. I was already inclined to return to Vienna for the birth of our son, when I learned that United Family charges about 120k CNY, but it would have been too complicated. Our daughter was born in a lovely Viennese hospital and the public insurance covered the costs of 1500 EUR, a 10th of what United Family charged our international insurance provider in the end. Can medical service be really so much better? No. And it actually wasn’t.
 
Again. I am not bashing individuals. I ask what we can change about the medical system, which has clearly gone awry in both the US, which has the highest per capita expenditure of all OECD countries, and China, where medicine has turned into one of the least sought after careers. Even safe havens like Austria will have to change their health systems, which are essentially low productivity government extensions, with overlapping markets of municipal, provincial and national hospitals.
 
One path into the future was explained this June during a TEDx Caohejing event by Mr. Zheng Jie, CEO of Sulan Health Group.  Mr. Zheng explored the future of medicine and referred substantially to the American physician Eric Topol (check out his TED talk), author of The Patient Will See You and The Creative Destruction of Medicine.  According to him, we will see a deconstruction of the “Gods in White”, and an increasing number of intelligent patients empowered by digital medicine, who will use physicians only to execute a decision they have made themselves. Massive Open Online Medicine (MOOM), the Internet of Medical Things (IoMT) and an unprecedented amount of personal medical data will provide the patient the required information to wield the power of decision, whereas the physician can increase the amount time spent to interact with his clients.
 
Such a utopian scenario does not take the economic factor into consideration, but its at least a plausible way forward. Authors like Martin Ford in Rise of the Robots are pessimistic about how economic dynamics will actually hamper the positive development of our increasingly digitalized health systems. In any case its high time to increase our self-awareness and self-responsibility.
 
Further reading:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hippocratic_Oath
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phimosis
http://shanghai.ufh.com.cn/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Health_insurance
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/8c/Health_Expenditure_per_capita_OECD_2013.png
http://www.shulanhealth.com/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Topol
http://www.ted.com/talks/eric_topol_the_wireless_future_of_medicine
http://www.mingong.org/blog/book-review-rise-of-robots-technology-and-the-threat-of-a-jobless-future
 
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All
    Aging
    Art
    Atonement
    Austria
    Bottom Up Focus
    Buddhism
    Calexico
    Capitalism
    Children
    China
    Cinema
    Climate Change
    Csr
    Democracy
    Denmark
    Digital Media
    Economics
    Education
    Enlightenment
    Europe
    Famous Quotes
    Football
    Hamburg
    Hansa
    Happiness
    Health
    History
    Humor
    Hungary
    Ibizagate
    Individuation
    Innovation
    Integration
    Kiting
    Kurt Schuschnig
    Learning
    Life Guidance
    Love
    Medicine
    Meditation
    Memory
    Meritokratie
    Music
    Nationalism
    Neos
    Nepotismus
    Neurology
    Neuroscience
    Nutrition
    Oxytocin
    Parenting
    Philippines
    Politics
    Psychology
    Religion
    Research And Development
    Scandinavia
    Sebastian Kurz
    Slovakia
    Snowboarding
    Spain
    Sports
    Success
    Suffizienz
    Taiji
    Taoism
    Taxation
    Technology Transfer
    Top Down Focus
    Traffic
    Travel
    Turkey
    Urbanization
    Vikings
    Wise Living
    Work
    Writing
    Yoga

    Archives

    January 2023
    November 2022
    September 2022
    May 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    December 2021
    March 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    July 2019
    February 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    October 2017
    August 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    September 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    August 2009

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly